Monday, April 30, 2012

American History X Review


1. What do you feel is the message the director is trying to express in this movie?  Support your answer with examples.

There are a few messages that I believe the directory tried to express in the movie. The most obvious is that whether we know or not chances are high that someone is looking up to us and wanting to be just like us. Derek was doing what he thought was right in the movement and didn’t think until much later that Danny, his little brother, was greatly influenced by his actions. Even though Derek had changed and became a better person Danny still had issues understanding that and realizing that his brother was wrong in everything that he did early on in his life. Another message is that it is in our nature to seek revenge. We don’t all do it in extremes like Derek, but we hold grudges when they really are pointless. Just because their father was killed by a black man Derek felt that it was necessary to punish every black man for what happened to his father. The strongest message I believe is that no matter how strongly we feel about something our views can quickly change. Derek hated everyone but the people in his circle and hurt so many people, but in the end he was one of the nicest people in the movie. Through some rough things he went through while in prison he realized that what he was doing was wrong. Unfortunately, we don’t all have opportunities that make us realize that what we are doing is wrong, but through time we can all still change and become better.

2. If applicable, discuss if you think this movie has accurate depictions of minorities or if they are situational? Why or why not?

The depictions of minorities are very situational in a way. Not all white people hate black people. Not all black people sell drugs and commit crimes. I feel that this question is tough to answer just because the depictions are accurate for some people especially during that time.

3. Explain if you think the director’s ethnic/cultural/professional background played a role in directing this film?

I wasn’t able to find much on the life of Tony Kaye, the director. I did find out that he threatened to have his name removed as the director because he wasn’t okay with the editing of the movie. It is obvious, though, that he understands all the tensions among racial groups and understands the importance of stopping it.

4. What groups (people of color, nationality, culture, class, gender etc.) may be offended or misinterpret this movie and why?

I think that people of all the different nationalities, cultures, class, and gender portrayed in the movie may be offended depending on how they look at the reasons behind the movie. It is very harsh and nothing was sugarcoated. I found myself angry so many times throughout it just because that kind of stuff has happened so much and still even exists in some places.

5. What the movie added to your visual literacy?

This movie showed how easily we can look at what someone is doing and come to admire it and follow it because we look up to that person that is doing it. We observe each other which is why it is important to realize that you never know when someone is looking at your actions.

6. What kind of artistic and/or visual means did the director use in the movie to focus our attention?

The scenes that were from the past were in black and white and the scenes after Derek got out of jail were in color. I think this was done to make it obvious to the viewer what used to be and what is. Also, it might have something to do with how our history was and the bright path that we are starting to follow.

No comments:

Post a Comment